I sure am a lucky guy! . . . for so many reasons . . . not the least of which is that over the past sixteen years I have had the chance to play with some of the most amazing artists in jazz. To the extent that I’ve accomplished anything myself as a musician, it’s been because of these opportunities.
I’ve (started to) learn how to play by consistently, eagerly (and at times perhaps even a bit naively) placing myself in situations where I’ve been in way over my head - getting my butt kicked by musicians of infinitely greater skill, experience, knowledge and talent. I never went to music school, but the bandstand has been my classroom.
And three of my greatest teachers have been Brad Mehldau, Christian McBride and Brian Blade. We all played together from 1993 through 1994, touring pretty much non-stop and recording one album, Moodswing, along the way. Nominally, I was the “leader” of the band. How absurd! Because it was of course I who was being led (propped-up, schooled, instructed, inspired, humbled, spoiled. . . you name it ) by these three musical geniuses (and I do not use that term lightly).
Being a “bandleader” was the best (and easiest!) job in the world. Of course, I knew this band wouldn’t last forever. But since New Years of 1995 (our last gig), I always looked forward to the day when the four of us would have a chance to play together again. Well, that day (or rather, night) just came. Exactly a week ago (May 4, 2007), Brad, Christian, Brian and I played two concerts at Herbst Theatre in San Francisco.
It was part of this year’s SFJAZZ Spring Season focus on the music of Thelonious Monk. The theme of these two concerts was the historic collaboration between Monk and John Coltrane. We played the tunes from their legendary Carnegie Hall performance of November 29, 1957 (almost 50 years ago): Crepescule With Nellie, Nutty, Evidence, Monk’s Mood, Epistrophy, Sweet and Lovely, Bye-Ya and Blue Monk. What fun! How inspring! (And again, for me, what an education!) On the surface, it might have seemed a little strange that we were coming back together to play this repertoire – as opposed to the music that we had performed and recorded fourteen years ago. But, in fact, it felt very natural, and appropriate. Monk and Trane have obviously been huge inspirations for us all, and it was a thrill to explore and celebrate their influence by approaching their music in our own way, through our own individual perspectives, and with our own collective sound. Obviously, we weren’t trying to “recreate” the Carnegie Hall concert. That would have been a doomed enterprise from the start.
But with Brad, Christian and Brian, imitation is never a danger, or even an issue. They have such uniquely powerful and mature artistic visions that they immediately take ownership of the material, crafting their own brilliant interpretations, while at the same time honoring the originals – not by the note, or by the style, but rather in the spirit. Oddly enough, for me, the most challenging moment came at the end of the second show, where for the encore we decided to try “Rejoice”, a tune of mine that we used to play quite a bit back in the day. It was also the only time during the whole night when I felt just ever-slow-slightly hampered by nostalgia.
Don’t get me wrong, it was a blast to play that tune again. But I guess I had so many strong memories of how we used to play it, that at times I felt like I was unconsciously trying to to conjure up a vibe from the past, as opposed to just being fully aware and conscious of the moment, creating and discovering the sound of the present. Next time (and I can’t wait for that next time!) I’ll know better: Even if we’re playing one of our “old tunes”, I should never expect us to get back to something old. On the contrary, the joy is in the possibility, and the process, of moving towards something new.
Walking off the bandstand at the end of the night, Christian commented, “Well, we sure don’t sound like we used to.” He’s right. We don’t. And we shouldn’t. A lot happens in fourteen years. And a lot changes. And we sounded different, as Brad so aptly put it, “in just about all the right ways.” But some things also remain the same. In our case, I think the connection, the camaraderie, the respect and the empathy are still there in force, perhaps stronger than ever. And for my part, I remain just as awed, inspired and humbled as ever by these three master musicians. Brad, Christian and Brian: Thanks again for yet another lesson. I look forward to many more, in the (hopefully not-too-distant) future!